Vocal lines are no longer memorable in death metal

Virtually every death metal band from the first wave had its share of infectious vocal lines. From Deicide to Dismember, death metal fans grew up memorizing and screaming morbid lyrics in much the same way their baby boomer parents may once have creamed their pants to The Beatles. Now, there is a school of thought that considers vocals and lyrics in death metal as somewhat superfluous to the actual music; while one can certainly enjoy death metal on instrumental terms alone, vocals when done right can be a useful percussive instrument, and when combined with evocative lyrics can enhance the band’s themes, perhaps just as much as the music itself.

This is not intended to be the usual “metal is dead, woe is us” screed; for all our frustration with hipster, manic-depressive attention whores co-opting our music, death metal continues to be in relatively rude health. But more to the point, just how many memorable vocal lines have we heard in death metal these last fifteen years? Forget being compelled to learn all of ‘Immortal Rites‘ by heart, can those reared on today’s death metal even think of something as succinct yet so legendary as a ‘Confront me!‘ or an ‘I’ll find peace when I’m God!‘ For all the tributes, both sincere and trendy, to old school death metal, it is curious that this one aspect seems to have flown entirely under the radar of new death metal musicians.

Perhaps vocalists aren’t considering themselves singers and lyricists anymore. Older bands came from a milieu that much closer to more traditional rock n roll where the singer’s participation in those twin roles was as important as the underlying instrumental arrangements. However, with the advent of Suffocation‘s syncopation-driven grinding and Incantation‘s chromatically-intense death metal, both styles that have since come to dominate the genre, vocal space that was once exclusively reserved came to be at a premium. Vocals slipped obscurely into the background as a mere coloring drone, and lyrics, not required to conform to set vocal niches anymore, became far more stream-of-consciousness, at times tediously abstruse. Neither development was favorable to presenting songs in the erstwhile “macabre parable” format. In some ways, severing that last association with accessibility was an inevitable progression for a music that takes pride in being extreme, but also lost in the process was a certain individuality and a once-vital tool for connecting with the listener.

This entry was posted in Death Metal, Thoughts and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Vocal lines are no longer memorable in death metal

  1. Lord Humungus says:

    I’d argue divine eve do a good job with their vocals, especially on As the Angels Weep

  2. Billy Foss says:

    I see a wealth of truth in that last line. I would liken the loss of memorable vocals to a severing of reality from morbid flights of fancy, and without that anchor of reality you run risk of plummeting into the depths of atmospherics for atmosphere’s sake. I always enjoyed learning the lyrics of a song, and took the extremity and verve with which they were delivered as motivation to memorize them similar to the passion that drives a linguist to decipher another language. This is why I can recite the entirety of ‘Crypts of Eternity’, but struggle with bands that I want to like that refuse to release lyric sheets or even write lyrics at all. In truth, lyrics are a multifaceted labor for everyone, for the artist to further refine their art and for the listener to understand the art so that they may both find meaning in things much larger than themselves.

    • Yeah, agreed. Vocals and lyrics are both important, and hopefully when done well simultaneously. Not sure where that places an outlier like Lord Worm in the scheme of things. But a vocalist shouldn’t exist to simply make up the numbers. He has to make his presence felt through force of personality; not at the cost of overwhelming the instruments but definitely as an enhancing agent.

      • Billy Foss says:

        “He has to make his presence felt through force of personality-”

        Exactly. And when it is done successfully, that is when you have a truly memorable vocal performance such as Martin Van Drunen on “The Rack” and “Consuming Impulse” or nearly anything Chris Reifert has ever done. Both of those men put in a lot of work throughout their careers and it shows. Through all the speed and distortion the instrumentation can become quite alienating which is the other path that you describe with Suffocation, but when you have such a wide range of vocal expression on display it serves to slice through all that and tether us to reality by reminding us of our humanity and thus our mortality.

  3. LordKrumb says:

    “Vocal lines are no longer memorable in death metal”

    I think the same can be said of memorable guitar solos in death metal.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s